Which VR Game is Best for Fitness? The Case for CleanSheet Soccer

Thursday, September 5, 2024
James Stafford

VR fitness games are gaining popularity, offering an immersive way to combine exercise with entertainment. But which is the best for fitness? One standout example is CleanSheet Soccer, a VR goalkeeping game designed to provide a full-body workout while improving reflexes and coordination. But how effective is CleanSheet Soccer compared to other VR fitness games? Let’s dive into an experiment that proves this game isn’t just about soccer—it's about serious fitness results.

Cover art of a goalkeeper playing CleanSheet Soccer saving an oncoming soccer ball
CleanSheet is available on Meta Quest and PSVR2

CleanSheet Soccer: A Real Fitness Experiment

We recently ran an experiment with a semi-professional goalkeeper to measure the fitness potential of CleanSheet Soccer. Equipped with a Polar heart rate monitor, the goalkeeper took on 15 minutes of the game’s professional quickfire mode. In this high-intensity mode, shots come fast and furious, keeping the player engaged both physically and mentally.

The results were impressive:

  • Session Duration: 15 minutes
  • Calories burned: 247
  • Average Heart rate: 164 beats per minute
  • Max Heart Rate: 187 beats per minute
  • Fat burn % of calories: 10% of the total calories burned were fat as opposed to other energy sources like carbohydrates or proteins

To put this into perspective, burning 247 calories in 15 minutes is on par with some of the most strenuous workouts, including HIIT (High-Intensity Interval Training) and sprinting. But the key difference here is that the player wasn’t just running on a treadmill—he was saving shots, diving, and staying constantly on his toes in a dynamic virtual soccer world.

An image of a breakdown of fitness analytics of a goalkeeper playing CleanS
The semi-pro goalkeeper dived frequently during the session which resulted in an impressive workout

Comparing CleanSheet Soccer to Other VR Fitness Games

While there are several VR games known for their fitness benefits, CleanSheet Soccer stands out in this area due to the high calorie burnt in a short amount of time. Here’s how it compares to some popular VR fitness games:

  • Beat Saber: combines rhythm, music, and lightsaber-style action to create an exciting workout. Players slash through incoming blocks (representing musical beats) with dual lightsabers in time to the music. Blocks come at varying speeds and directions, requiring players to squat, dodge obstacles, and make full-body movements. The fast-paced action helps improve hand-eye coordination, reflexes, and overall cardiovascular fitness. Each song features different difficulty levels, making it accessible for both beginners and seasoned players.
  • Fitness Focus:
    • Cardiovascular endurance
    • Upper body movement and coordination
    • Reaction speed
An image of a Beat Saber player cuts through an oncoming cube
Beat Saber offers an intense workout by slashing oncoming cubes

  • Supernatural: offers a more structured, coach-led workout experience with virtual personal trainers guiding you through daily routines. Set in stunning, immersive environments like mountaintops or tropical beaches, the workouts involve using batons to hit targets in time with music, squatting, lunging, and dodging obstacles. With a variety of workout types ranging from low-impact to high-intensity, this VR fitness game targets the whole body. The library includes playlists set to a range of music genres, making the experience feel like a high-energy, music-driven exercise class.
  • Fitness Focus:
    • Full-body workouts (arms, legs, core)
    • Cardio, strength, and flexibility
    • Guided training programs
An image of a Supernatural player striking an onc
Similar to Beat Saber, Supernatural allowes you to strike targets in rhytm to music

  • Thrill of the Fight: a realistic boxing simulator where players face off against AI opponents in a virtual ring. It offers an intense workout by mimicking real boxing movements such as jabs, hooks, and defensive blocks. The game measures your punches' force and speed while encouraging agility and endurance as you dodge, weave, and counter punches. With no breaks between rounds, the game can be quite challenging, burning calories while improving reflexes, footwork, and upper-body strength. It's a high-intensity workout suited for those seeking a realistic combat sport experience.
  • Fitness Focus:
    • High-intensity interval training (HIIT)
    • Strength, stamina, and endurance
    • Upper body (arms, shoulders, core) and cardiovascular fitness

An image of a person wearing a VR headset defending a punch from Thrill of the Fight's VR AI
Thrill of the fight requires you to box virtual AI

The Science Behind the Burn: Heart Rate and Full-Body Engagement

The goalkeeper’s heart rate was near maximum for most of the 15-minute session, which speaks to the cardiovascular intensity of CleanSheet Soccer. But what makes this VR game so effective for fitness compared to the previous VR games mentioned? It comes down to the physical demands:

  • Explosive Movements: Diving, jumping, and lunging to save virtual soccer balls requires the same athleticism as real goalkeeping. This engages muscles in the legs, core, and upper body, creating a full-body workout.
  • High Intensity: The quickfire mode keeps the action fast-paced, meaning there’s no downtime. You’re constantly moving, reacting, and working your body hard.
  • Immersive Environment: Unlike traditional workouts, where fatigue can make you want to quit early, CleanSheet Soccer keeps you mentally locked in. The immersive VR environment makes it feel like you’re really in the game, saving shots instead of doing a workout. This helps you push harder and keep going for longer.

Why CleanSheet Soccer is the Best VR Game for Fitness

If you’re looking for a VR game that gives you more than just entertainment, CleanSheet Soccer is your best bet. It’s not just about perfecting your goalkeeping skills—this game offers one of the most effective, full-body VR workouts available.

Here are the key reasons why CleanSheet Soccer is a fitness game-changer:

  • High calorie burn: Burning 247 calories in 15 minutes is impressive, and few other VR or traditional workouts can match that.
  • Full-body engagement: Unlike many VR fitness games that focus on the upper body, CleanSheet Soccer involves everything—from legs to core to arms—resulting in a more comprehensive workout.
  • Cardio and coordination: The game keeps your heart rate up while also requiring sharp mental focus and hand-eye coordination, making it a unique blend of cardio and skill training.
  • Fun factor: The immersive nature of VR means you’re more likely to stick with your workout routine. After all, it’s hard to get bored when you're saving game-winning goals!

Conclusion: Fitness That Feels Like Fun

In a world where VR gaming is rapidly evolving, CleanSheet Soccer stands out not only for its skill-building potential but for its significant fitness benefits. Whether you’re an athlete looking to stay in shape or just someone who wants to add more fun to their workouts, this VR game can deliver intense, effective exercise in as little as 15 minutes.

Published:
September 5, 2024
Updated:
September 9, 2024

Read More